page 20 |
Previous | 21 of 60 | Next |
|
This page
All
|
Loading content ...
Philosophy, Literature, and Dogma: Santayana and the View from Somewhere I do not pretend to place myself at the heart of the universe nor at its origin, nor to draw its periphery. I would lay siege to the truth, only as animal exploration and fancy may do so, first from one quarter and then from another, expecting the reality to be not simpler than my experience of it, but far more extensive and complex. I stand in philosophy exactly where I stand in daily life; I should not be honest otherwise.1 —Santayana, "Preface," Scepticism and Animal Faith Viewed from a sufficient distance, all systems of philosophy are seen to be personal, temperamental, accidental, and premature. They treat partial knowledge as if it were total knowledge. ... In a word, they are human heresies. ... I can imagine a man becoming a philosopher without being a heretic. ... It [doing so] lies in confessing that a system of philosophy is a personal work of art which gives a specious unity to some chance vista in the cosmic labyrinth. To confess this is to confess a notorious truth; yet it would be something novel if a philosopher should confess it, and should substitute the pursuit of sincerity for the pursuit of omniscience.2 —Santayana, "Philosophical Heresy," Obiter Scripta People live differently from other people. They speak different languages, have different friends and families, wear different clothes, seek different kinds of shelter, eat different foods, use different tools, make different music, play different games, tell different stories, find different things sad and funny, take on different habits and exhibit different vision and also different blindness, undertake different inquiries, set forth different assertions and theories, take different things as obvious and natural, pursue different passions and realize fulfillment in different loves, suffer different fears and pains, fight different battles, worship different gods, and imagine different ideals. They also develop and pledge allegiance to different philosophies. Sometimes these differences appear as an immense resource and profound wealth, remarkable triumphs of life and will and spirit in different times and different places. At other times these differences may appear as resilient roadblocks, parochial barriers to common enterprises, shared community, and a wider beauty, greater justice and larger truth. To repeat: People live differently from other people. These differences extend to, and include, philosophy or, more accurately, philosophies. People hold, defend, and develop different philosophies. The long history of philosophy makes this evident, and even a short poll of persons who come across this essay would yield further evidence. The philosophies of Aristotle, Jesus, Augustine, Hobbes, Zera Yacob, Spinoza, Mulla Sadra, Kierkegaard, Marx, William James, Santayana, Ayn Rand, and Derrida: These are different philosophies. 1 George Santayana, Scepticism and Animal Faith (New York: Scribner's Sons, 1923), v-vi. 2 George Santayana, "Philosophical Heresy," Obiter Scripta (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1936), 94, 100.
Object Description
Description
Title | page 20 |
Item ID | BulletinSantayana2013-021_page 20.tiff |
Standardized Rights Statement | http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC-EDU/1.0/ |
Transcript | Philosophy, Literature, and Dogma: Santayana and the View from Somewhere I do not pretend to place myself at the heart of the universe nor at its origin, nor to draw its periphery. I would lay siege to the truth, only as animal exploration and fancy may do so, first from one quarter and then from another, expecting the reality to be not simpler than my experience of it, but far more extensive and complex. I stand in philosophy exactly where I stand in daily life; I should not be honest otherwise.1 —Santayana, "Preface," Scepticism and Animal Faith Viewed from a sufficient distance, all systems of philosophy are seen to be personal, temperamental, accidental, and premature. They treat partial knowledge as if it were total knowledge. ... In a word, they are human heresies. ... I can imagine a man becoming a philosopher without being a heretic. ... It [doing so] lies in confessing that a system of philosophy is a personal work of art which gives a specious unity to some chance vista in the cosmic labyrinth. To confess this is to confess a notorious truth; yet it would be something novel if a philosopher should confess it, and should substitute the pursuit of sincerity for the pursuit of omniscience.2 —Santayana, "Philosophical Heresy," Obiter Scripta People live differently from other people. They speak different languages, have different friends and families, wear different clothes, seek different kinds of shelter, eat different foods, use different tools, make different music, play different games, tell different stories, find different things sad and funny, take on different habits and exhibit different vision and also different blindness, undertake different inquiries, set forth different assertions and theories, take different things as obvious and natural, pursue different passions and realize fulfillment in different loves, suffer different fears and pains, fight different battles, worship different gods, and imagine different ideals. They also develop and pledge allegiance to different philosophies. Sometimes these differences appear as an immense resource and profound wealth, remarkable triumphs of life and will and spirit in different times and different places. At other times these differences may appear as resilient roadblocks, parochial barriers to common enterprises, shared community, and a wider beauty, greater justice and larger truth. To repeat: People live differently from other people. These differences extend to, and include, philosophy or, more accurately, philosophies. People hold, defend, and develop different philosophies. The long history of philosophy makes this evident, and even a short poll of persons who come across this essay would yield further evidence. The philosophies of Aristotle, Jesus, Augustine, Hobbes, Zera Yacob, Spinoza, Mulla Sadra, Kierkegaard, Marx, William James, Santayana, Ayn Rand, and Derrida: These are different philosophies. 1 George Santayana, Scepticism and Animal Faith (New York: Scribner's Sons, 1923), v-vi. 2 George Santayana, "Philosophical Heresy," Obiter Scripta (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1936), 94, 100. |
Tags
Comments
Post a Comment for page 20